Season	School	Record
2014-2015	Indianapolis Lutheran	9-16
2013-2014	Indianapolis Lutheran	10-11
2012-2013	Indianapolis Lutheran	9-11
2011-2012	Indianapolis Lutheran	10-12
2010-2011	Indianapolis Lutheran	5-17
2009-2010	Indianapolis Lutheran	13-11
2008-2009	Indianapolis Lutheran	10-11
2007-2008	Indianapolis Lutheran	22-5
2006-2007	Indianapolis Lutheran	14-7
2005-2006	Indianapolis Lutheran	7-14
2004-2005	Indianapolis Lutheran	11-10
2003-2004	Indianapolis Lutheran	5-15
2002-2003	Indianapolis Lutheran	4-15
2001-2002	Indianapolis Lutheran	6-14
2000-2001	Indianapolis Lutheran	11-10
1999-2000	Indianapolis Lutheran	5-15
1998-1999	Indianapolis Lutheran	11-9
1997-1998	Indianapolis Lutheran	5-15
1996-1997	Indianapolis Lutheran	10-11
1995-1996	Indianapolis Lutheran	12-8
1994-1995	Indianapolis Lutheran	8-12
1993-1994	Indianapolis Lutheran	14-6